How To Write A Paper Headline . Headline generator results using underscores headline generator results using [blank] write down another 25 headlines (you could also copy paste them into your word processor; Personally i prefer pencil and paper or sticky notes). MLA Style Paper Layout of First Page Jerz's Literacy Weblog (est. 1999) from jerz.setonhill.edu Writing a newspaper headline 1. Headings at the same level should be formatted the same. Once you’re ready to write catchy headlines, it’s helpful to test them out first.